As many of you know, my humom loves tech gadgets and loves to try new products, including the ones that makes our lives more comfortable, especially when we hurt or get sick.
I have some irritation going on with one of my paws right now. To keep me from licking it, she has to put something around my neck. When she first got one of those huge cones they give you at vet, she noticed how much I hate them. I get depressed and listless when I have to wear them. Furthermore, my mobility is reduced and I constantly bump into things.
So, she sought better imagined alternatives… So this is the list of ones she got for me and I tried. Here is my take on them:
- Comfy Cone Pet E-Collar (newer version with stays for structure)
It’s a great e-collar. It’s very soft, easy to clean and makes it easy to move around and sleep in. It’s not transparent like most plastic e-cones, but it does the job. The only drawback is that the collar loops are a bit too small to fit a standard or large dog collar to be used with the cone (for stability)–it will still work fine even if you do not attach the cone to the dog collar via the loops.
- Novaguard Collar
The is another great one. The design is more compact and has space for my ears outside the cone space so I can hear better. Also, the cone is narrower than the traditional e-collar. The big plus is that it is clear which allows me to see everything around me. The only minus is that my vet said I looked like Hannibal Lecter.
- BiteNot Collar
In concept it looks good, but when I tried it, I hated it. I felt traumatized. It was like wearing one of those neck braces I see the humans wearing when they hurt their necks. It does limit my licking mobility and has some comfort (foam inside the collar), but the big drawback is that the plastic corners poked into my neck especially when I ran down the stairs, so it wasn’t good for me and mom didn’t want to use it again. They could have added cushioning or rounded the corners, or they could have used the same material as the Comfy Cone rather than plastic.
There are too many options out there, so we haven’t been able to try every single one (unless they were given to us for free to test). Here are some other alternatives humom has read about but we have not tried:
- Hager Collar
It looks like a cross between a BiteNot and ComfyCone combined. The great thing about it is that is can be cut and adjusted to fit as stated on the Web site.
- Trimline Recovery Collar
It looks similar to the Comfy Cone, but from seeing the videos, they looks too thin and too flimsy to keep me from getting to my paws. It doesn’t seem to have the structure other collars usually have. Might work better for some depending on how you are with boo-boos.
In the end, between soft and not being able to see or having a clear compact collar that allows me to see around, the two best ones I’ve tried have been both the Comfy Cone and the Novaguard.
I’d do the Novaguard for outside walks even if I look like Hannibal Lecter and the Comfy Cone for inside the house.
Have you used any of the other alternate e-collars? What are your thoughts on them?